Barriers to AI in Healthcare

Artificial Intelligence: from science fiction to Healthcare transformation.

Healthcare has made significant progress over the last two decades, with improvements in life expectancy and quality of life worldwide.

However, the growing aging population presents new challenges for healthcare systems, creating a need for more efficient long-term care management and solutions to meet the increasing demand for care.

As many healthcare market research agencies will testify, artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a powerful tool with the potential to revolutionize healthcare delivery. What was once a concept reserved for science fiction is now a critical part of modern healthcare, helping to address some of the most pressing challenges faced by providers, patients, and policymakers alike.

AI is already making a tangible impact in several key areas of healthcare, such as:

• Disease Detection and Diagnosis: AI models are now routinely used for early detection of conditions like cancer, heart disease, and neurological disorders, often providing more accurate and timely results than traditional diagnostic methods.
• Personalized Medicine: AI is enabling the development of personalized treatment plans by analyzing vast amounts of patient data, leading to more effective and targeted therapies.
• Operational Efficiency: AI-driven tools help streamline administrative tasks, such as scheduling, billing, and patient management, reducing operational costs and freeing up resources for patient care.
• Remote Monitoring and Virtual Health: AI-powered platforms are facilitating remote patient monitoring, telemedicine, and virtual assistants, allowing clinicians to deliver care more effectively, especially to elderly or chronically ill patients.

Despite these successes, significant barriers remain to the widespread adoption of AI in healthcare, including:

• Data Privacy and Security: Healthcare data is incredibly sensitive, and AI systems require access to large datasets, which raises concerns around patient confidentiality, data security, and compliance.
• Integration with Existing Systems: Many healthcare systems rely on legacy infrastructure that isn’t easily integrated with advanced AI tools. Adopting AI requires not only technological investment but also overcoming resistance to change and retraining.
• Ethical Concerns: AI systems need to be transparent, fair, and accountable, particularly in areas like diagnostics and decision-making, to avoid biases that could affect patient outcomes.
• Regulatory Hurdles: The development and approval of AI-based medical devices and solutions must go through rigorous testing and regulatory processes, which can slow down the introduction of these innovations into clinical practice.

Nonetheless, the potential benefits of AI in healthcare are undeniable, and ongoing advancements are likely to continue shaping the future of medicine. As the technology matures and healthcare systems adapt, AI will play an increasingly critical role in addressing the challenges posed by an aging population and rising healthcare costs.

3 Key barriers to AI that exist in healthcare:

1. Regulations

A significant barrier to the adoption of AI in healthcare is the regulatory landscape. Different countries have distinct regulatory frameworks, but for the purposes of this discussion, we’ll focus on the United States.

In 2021, the FDA took a major step in clarifying its stance on the regulation of AI and machine learning (ML) in medical devices with an updated action plan. This plan addresses the challenges surrounding software-as-a-medical-device (SaMD) and offers a roadmap for how the FDA intends to approach AI-powered medical technologies. As AI and ML continue to evolve, the FDA's efforts to regulate AI-based medical devices are also expanding, focusing on maintaining safety while enabling innovation.

According to FDA guidelines in the US, AI software programmes and devices are most likely to fall under Class 3.

Class 3 is defined as high risk. This represents ~10% of medical devices on the market and is the primary category where artificial intelligent systems fall into. They can pose serious threats to patients if they malfunction.

Whilst most AI software programmes and devices serve to assist medical professionals, it’s difficult to say whether these devices will override the judgement of health professionals.

This leads us onto the next hurdle: Patient and provider trust. Even if the FDA does approve these medical devices, will they be trusted?

2. Patient and provider trust

AI is becoming more common in various industries, from finance to logistics, but healthcare is unique in the stakes it carries. AI-powered systems that make treatment recommendations can be perceived as both a benefit and a risk. For example, AI can aid in disease detection and decision support, but it is also seen as unfamiliar and sometimes "black-box" technology.

Recent surveys, such as one conducted by Intel and Convergys Analytics, show that 91% of healthcare decision-makers see the potential benefits of AI, including improvements in quality of care and operational efficiency. However, 54% express concerns about AI potentially compromising patient safety.

While AI’s promises are huge—such as IBM’s Watson for Oncology, which aimed to revolutionize cancer treatment—the technology has faced criticism for failing to deliver on its initial promises. Investigations have shown that Watson sometimes struggles to differentiate between cancer types and provide actionable, contextually accurate recommendations. Additionally, some international users have raised concerns about biases in Watson’s algorithm that align with U.S.-centric healthcare models, further highlighting trust issues.

Transparency is key in addressing these concerns. Both patients and providers need to understand why AI makes certain recommendations, and the need for clarity in AI’s decision-making process is paramount. Educating healthcare providers on how these technologies work and building transparency around the algorithms will help improve trust and acceptance.

3. Privacy and Cybersecurity concerns

Another significant challenge in the AI-driven healthcare ecosystem is privacy and data security. AI requires access to vast amounts of sensitive data, and the more AI systems are integrated into healthcare, the greater the concerns about data protection.

In some cases, data anonymization can make it easier to use AI without compromising privacy. However, in certain use cases, such as diagnostic imaging (e.g., ultrasounds or CT scans), privacy remains a key concern. Moreover, as healthcare data becomes a prime target for cybercriminals, AI's growing role in cybersecurity is crucial. AI-enabled systems are already being used to monitor and identify cybersecurity threats in real time, detecting vulnerabilities more effectively than traditional methods.

The rise of cyberattacks also underscores the need for robust, AI-driven security solutions. While AI can improve security by detecting threats and protecting data, human oversight is still essential to address context-specific issues that AI may not be able to process.

Looking ahead: the future of AI in Healthcare:

AI in healthcare is still in its early stages, and we are just beginning to scratch the surface of its potential. AI’s ability to analyze massive datasets, detect complex patterns, and assist in clinical decision-making is unparalleled, making it a powerful tool in the healthcare space. Yet, for AI to be successfully integrated into mainstream healthcare, trust—must be earned.

The widespread adoption of AI in healthcare is not without challenges, but these obstacles—ranging from regulatory hurdles to concerns about privacy, trust, and bias—are gradually being addressed. As the technology matures, AI has the potential to transform healthcare, but human oversight and transparency will remain crucial for its success.

As one of the UK’s leading healthcare market research agencies, IDR Medical has over a decade of experience in conducting market research tailored to healthcare markets. In fact, we have conducted projects in over 30 countries to drive success of brands, products, and services of our clients.

If you are interested in conducting a market research project do not hesitate to contact us. We would be delighted to offer an initial telephone discussion, or an online meeting to understand how we can assist you.

Contact us today